One porch light burns among identical dark houses in a misty cul-de-sac before dawn, a child's purple bicycle lying on the lawn below it. Cover art for Porch Pickup on dailycreepypasta.com.

Porch Pickup

4 min read

Content notes: a child taken from her family (implied)

Curbcast: Curb alert near you! FREE — White dresser, one knob missing. Porch pickup only, 6 AM.

The photo is your daughter’s dresser.

You know because of the knob. Josie pulled it off in June to see if it would bounce. It did. It went under the radiator and it lives there now.


You live in Brightwater Ridge. Two hundred houses, four floor plans, and every third one is the Wexford. Three bedrooms, a bonus nook, the kitchen island everyone’s ex-wife picked out.

You got the house in the divorce. You got Josie every other week and every Tuesday. You can afford the mortgage if nothing breaks.

Everyone here is on Curbcast. The HOA told them to. It’s how the neighborhood gets rid of strollers and treadmills and the second air fryer. Josie scrolls it for bikes.

So: same builder, same dresser, same flat-pack hardware. Somebody else’s kid pulled off a knob. You laugh about it, a little.

The listing says 0.0 mi away. The poster is Neighbor in Brightwater Ridge. No photo. No history.

At 9:31 the button turns grey.

Claimed!


At 6:00 your doorbell camera records nothing. No car. No porch light. A moth.

At 6:20 you go to wake Josie, and the dresser is gone.

Four dents in the carpet. Her socks in a neat pile where the bottom drawer used to be, like someone emptied it first. Considerate.

The officer who comes out asks about your ex. You change the locks anyway.

You report the listing.

Thanks for helping keep Curbcast neighborly! Our team reviewed this listing and found that it doesn’t violate our Community Guidelines.


It happens again at 9:15 the next night. The exact minute.

FREE — Kids’ bike, purple, streamers. Porch pickup only, 6 AM.

The bike is leaning in your garage, against your recycling bin, under your bare bulb. Josie’s bike. Same streamers.

Under the photo: 2 neighbors are interested.

You don’t think about it. You’re faster than them. You tap I’ll take it!

Claimed! You’re all set. Please be on time. Your neighbor is counting on you.

You sit up with the garage door open and a baseball bat across your knees, feeling like an idiot.

At 6:00 the doorbell chimes. Once.

The bike is on your porch.

You go to the garage. Josie’s bike is still there.

Two purple bikes. Same streamers. The one on the porch has a sticker on the crossbar, in sparkly vinyl letters: HADLEY.


You don’t know a Hadley.

At lunch the HOA group lights up.

Did anybody see who took a purple bike out of our garage last night?? Door was locked. Camera shows nothing. My daughter is devastated. — 4219 Brightwater Ct.

4219 is a Wexford.

You look at the photos again. The dresser. The garage. The same bulb, the same bin, the same builder-grade everything. You were never looking at your house. You were looking at a Wexford.

So the rule is: if you claim it, you get it. Whoever it belongs to doesn’t.

You could walk the bike over. You could knock and explain this.

You put it in your car and drive it to a donation bin across town, because there’s no version of explaining this where you keep your kid.


The third night, you’re ready. You have the app open at 9:14.

At 9:15:

FREE — Girl, 9. Sweet, reads a lot, scared of the dark. Porch pickup only, 6 AM.

The photo is a dark bedroom. Glow-in-the-dark stars on the ceiling. The builder put those in every Wexford’s second bedroom; it was part of the Family Ready package. A comforter with moons on it, from the big box store on Route 9, the one everybody has. A shape under the comforter, turned to the wall. A little hair on the pillow. Brown.

You can’t see her face.

Josie is asleep down the hall. You can hear the fan she needs on to sleep.

3 neighbors are interested.

You don’t know if this is your house.

You know that in about five seconds somebody else is going to decide for you.

4 neighbors are interested.

You tap I’ll take it!

Claimed! Thanks for giving this item a second home.


You don’t sleep. You sit on the floor outside Josie’s door with your back against it so nobody can open it without going through you. Every time the fan changes pitch your heart stops.

At 5:58 you can’t stand it. You open the door.

Josie is there. On her side, facing the wall, one sock off. Breathing.

You almost laugh. You put your hand on her back to feel it go up and down, and it does.

So it wasn’t yours.

At 6:00 the doorbell chimes. Once.

You already know what is standing on the porch. You go down anyway, because you claimed it, because you said you’d be on time.

She’s barefoot. Moon pajamas. Brown hair. Holding a flashlight that’s switched off. She doesn’t look scared. She looks like a kid who woke up somewhere new and is waiting to be told where to put her things.

Behind her, across the court, the porch light comes on at 4219.

Then a man’s voice, and then a woman’s, going room to room in the Wexford across the street, calling for Hadley.

AI was involved in writing this story.