
Period of Record
Content notes: hospitalized elderly parent, missing person
NATIONAL WEATHER SERVICE: COOPERATIVE OBSERVER PROGRAM
Quality Control Flag Summary
Station: Coldwater Flat 3 N, Montana
Observer: Wendell Sorlie (observing since June 1974; 50-Year Length of Service Award, 2024)
Observation time: 7:00 a.m. local
Generated: 10/20, 05:30
Flag: Precipitation reported on five of six days with no supporting data. Neighboring cooperative stations, the nearest automated airport station and radar estimates all show zero for 10/14 through 10/19. Observer reports clear skies on all six days.
| Date | Reported precipitation (in.) |
|---|---|
| 10/14 | 0.12 |
| 10/15 | 0.04 |
| 10/16 | 0.00 |
| 10/17 | 0.31 |
| 10/18 | 0.07 |
| 10/19 | 0.19 |
Remarks field, 10/14: “Reading taken by T. Sorlie. Dad in hospital in Billings since 10/12 (fall). He asked me to keep it going.”
Routed to: Observing Program Leader.
From: Kiran Basu, Observing Program Leader
To: Tamsin Sorlie
Date: 10/21, 09:14
Subject: Coldwater Flat 3 N readings
Ms. Sorlie,
Thank you for keeping the station going, and I’m sorry about your father. He has one of the longest records in the state. Six missed days in fifty-two years.
The gauge has been reporting rain on clear mornings. That nearly always has a simple cause: dew, a sprinkler, splash from a stock tank, or the overflow can getting measured twice. Could you walk me through how you take the reading?
Kiran
From: Tamsin Sorlie
To: Kiran Basu
Date: 10/21, 22:47
Subject: RE: Coldwater Flat 3 N readings
The way he taught me when I was nine. Lift the funnel off. Lower the stick into the inner tube, pull it out, read where the wet stops. If the tube is full, that’s two inches, and you pour the overflow can back through the tube to measure the rest. Empty everything. Put it all back. Seven o’clock, not five past.
There’s no sprinkler. There are no cows anymore. The stock tank has been dry since August.
I’ll be honest, I don’t love that gauge. I was born the spring after the big storm of ‘76, and Mom, Corinne, who died in 2011, used to say he still made the seven a.m. reading the morning I was born. He missed my graduation for it. He doesn’t remember most days now, but he remembers the gauge. So I’m reading it.
Also, you said six missed days. Which six? Mom always told me he never missed one.
MEMO TO STATION FILE
Author: K. Basu
Date: 10/28, 16:30
Re: Coldwater Flat 3 N, repeating values
Precipitation has now been reported on thirteen of the fifteen days since 10/14. Skies clear on all fifteen.
I checked the values against the station’s own period of record. Every daily total since 10/14 matches the total recorded at this station on the same date in 1976, to the hundredth of an inch. October 17, 1976: point three one. October 17, 2026: point three one. Fifteen of fifteen, including both zeros.
Most likely explanation: the observer’s old paper forms are kept in the house, and someone is copying from them. I’ve asked Ms. Sorlie to box the binders and leave them at the county extension office. She agreed without arguing.
For reference, the six missing days are November 18 through 23, 1976. No remarks were filed for them. The day before the gap, November 17, 1976, holds the station’s largest one-day total on record: two point four zero inches of water, with nineteen inches of new snow. If the pattern holds, two point four zero comes due on the morning of November 17.
VOICEMAIL TRANSCRIPT
Forwarded by: T. Sorlie to K. Basu, 10/31, 08:02
Caller: Wendell Sorlie (hospital room phone)
Received: 10/30, 06:58
Transcribed by: phone service
“Tam. It’s Dad. They’ve got me in a bed by the window, and it’s clear here. Clear as anything. [pause] Don’t bother with the binders. It isn’t coming out of the binders. [pause] You always did read it right the first time. You were the only one who ever did. [pause] Wear your coat out there. The good one. [inaudible] Seven o’clock. Bye now.”
SITE VISIT REPORT
Station: Coldwater Flat 3 N
Visit: 11/03, 15:10 to 11/04, 07:40
By: K. Basu, OPL
Equipment: Eight-inch standard rain gauge on a wooden post, about forty feet west of the house. Funnel, inner measuring tube and overflow can in good condition. No leaks. Level. Nothing overhanging. Snowboard and snow-depth stake beside it.
Binders: Removed by the observer’s daughter on 10/29. I confirmed they are at the extension office.
Test: At 15:40 on 11/03 I emptied and dried the gauge, taped the funnel to the overflow can, and fitted numbered tamper seal 0417. I stayed overnight on the couch. Ms. Sorlie and I took turns at the kitchen window, which faces the gauge. Sky clear all night. Wind light from the southwest. No person or animal approached the gauge.
Result: At 07:00 on 11/04, seal 0417 was intact. The inner tube held point two two inches. The 1976 value for November 4 is point two two.
The water is cold and clear and has no smell. Sample bottled for the lab.
There was also about an inch and a half of fresh snow on the snowboard, and only on the board. The ground around it was bare and dry. Air temperature at the time, forty-one degrees.
Recommendation: Equipment is sound. I can’t explain the readings. Leaving the station open pending review.
TEXT MESSAGES
Between: Tamsin Sorlie and Kiran Basu, 11/16
Tamsin (10:41 p.m.): Are you awake
Kiran (10:44 p.m.): Yes. What’s wrong?
Tamsin (10:45 p.m.): There’s wind out at the gauge.
Kiran (10:45 p.m.): It’s dead calm at the airport.
Tamsin (10:46 p.m.): It’s calm here too. The flag on the porch isn’t moving. But forty feet out it sounds like the blizzard from every story he ever told. Hissing. Snow hitting the side of the house in handfuls. Except nothing is hitting the house.
Tamsin (10:47 p.m.): I can see stars right over it.
Kiran (10:48 p.m.): Stay inside. Please. I’m suspending the station tonight.
Tamsin (10:52 p.m.): I called Dad. The night nurse held the phone up for him. I told him I could hear it out there. He said good, then she’d be there by seven. Then he asked if I’d found my coat.
Kiran (10:53 p.m.): Who’d be there by seven?
Tamsin (11:20 p.m.): It’s louder. It’s right at the gauge now and it isn’t moving.
From: Kiran Basu
To: Tamsin Sorlie
CC: Station file
Date: 11/16, 23:31
Subject: Coldwater Flat 3 N suspended
Ms. Sorlie,
Effective now, Coldwater Flat 3 N is suspended. Please do not take the reading on November 17. Please don’t go out to the gauge at all. A missed day will not count against your father’s record. I will mark it as program-directed.
I’m driving out first thing.
Kiran
From: Tamsin Sorlie
To: Kiran Basu
Date: 11/17, 05:12
Subject: RE: Coldwater Flat 3 N suspended
Thank you. I mean that.
He has asked me for one thing in my whole life. Seven o’clock, not five past.
I found the good coat.
DAILY OBSERVATION ENTRY (ONLINE)
Station: Coldwater Flat 3 N
Date: 11/17
Entered: 07:04, observer account, from mobile
Precipitation: 2.40 in. (inner tube full, overflow 0.40)
Snowfall: 19.0 in.
Snow depth: 31 in.
Remarks: “Can’t see the house from here. Somebody’s coming out with a lantern.”
No entries 11/18 through 11/23.
MEMO TO STATION FILE
Author: K. Basu
Date: 11/24, 11:05
I arrived at Coldwater Flat on 11/17 at 09:20. Sky clear. Ground bare and dry. Gauge upright on its post, funnel off, measuring stick lying across the snowboard. The house was unlocked and warm, with the porch light on. Ms. Sorlie was not on the property. Sheriff’s office notified at 09:41. The search is ongoing.
Hospital staff say Mr. Sorlie has not been told. Each morning at seven he asks whether the reading went in.
I requested the scanned November 1976 form from the national climate archive, to see whether the observer ever explained the six missing days. It arrived this morning. The daily columns for the 18th through the 23rd are blank. There is one handwritten note in the margin beside the 17th. Transcribed below. The reverse of the form was not scanned.
OBSERVATION FORM, NOVEMBER 1976, COLDWATER FLAT 3 N
Margin note beside day 17, observer’s handwriting. Transcribed by K. Basu.
“2.40. Worst I’ve seen. Went out at seven and found a woman already at the gauge, in a good coat, stick in her hand, reading it right. She knew about the overflow. Says she’s ours. We haven’t got any yet.
Corinne put her in the baby’s room.”
AI was involved in writing this story.