
Instructor Intervention
There are eleven instructor interventions in Car 2’s log from October that I did not make. I wrote every one of them down myself, in my own handwriting, because that’s the job. I just wasn’t the one who pressed the brake.
I teach driver’s ed in Muncie, Indiana. Days, mostly. I pick kids up from the high school at ten after three, run two lessons before dinner, and do Saturdays from eight to noon. It’s not a bad job. The kids are scared, and they’re scared of the right things, which is more than you can say for most adults on McGalliard Road.
Car 2 is a silver sedan with a dual-control brake. If you’ve never seen one, it’s a second brake pedal bolted to the floor on the passenger side. A steel rod runs under the dash and hooks onto the arm of the real pedal, so when I push mine, theirs goes down too. It makes a hollow clunk, like somebody dropping a boot in a closet. The kids hate that sound. It means they missed something.
Every time I use it, I write it in the log. Date, time, location, what happened. The state doesn’t need that much detail, but parents ask, and it keeps me honest.
The first one was a Tuesday, on Jackson Street, with a student I’ll call Noor. She was sixteen and careful to the point of crawling. Dry road, good light, nobody around. We were doing maybe twenty.
Clunk.
The car stopped hard. Noor’s hands came off the wheel. My feet were flat on the floor mat. I remember looking down at them, my two brown work shoes, side by side, nowhere near the pedal.
One second. Two.
A kid on a scooter shot out from between two parked vans, right where our front bumper would have been.
Noor turned and looked at me like I’d saved his life. I didn’t correct her. I wrote it down: Jackson and Hackley, scooter, instructor intervention. Then I sat there with the pen for a minute before I started the next line.
I took it to Rudy, who does the fleet work for the school out of a two-bay garage on Kilgore. Rudy has installed more dual brakes than anyone in the county. He got on his back in the passenger footwell with a flashlight in his teeth and came out with a spring in his hand.
“Return spring’s stretched,” he said. “You hit a pothole, the rod drops, the pedal goes down. Happens.”
“It stopped the car,” I said. “Hard.”
“Then it was a big pothole.”
He put a new spring on. He charged the school forty dollars. For six days nothing happened, and I felt stupid for every minute I’d spent thinking about it.
The seventh day was a Saturday, a boy named Caleb, eight in the morning on Tillotson. Clunk. My feet flat. One, two. A pickup came through the red light at the cross street doing fifty, and Caleb said a word I’m not allowed to write in the log.
That time I had proof. The school put cameras in all three cars last year for insurance. One looks out the windshield, and one looks back into the cabin, wide enough to see the footwells. I watched it that night at my kitchen table.
On the cabin view, the passenger pedal goes down by itself. You can see my shoes right next to it, not moving. On the road view, two seconds later, the pickup.
I watched it nine times. Then I did something I’m not proud of. I started trusting it.
I don’t mean I stopped paying attention. I mean I relaxed. For eighteen years I’ve ridden with my right foot hovering, my whole body leaning into every intersection like I can push the car back with my spine. And now there was something in the car that saw things two seconds before I did, and it was on my side.
My daughter Lainey had just gotten her learner’s permit. She’s fifteen. I’d been dreading it since she was born, and that week I came home and told her I’d take her out myself on Sunday. Her school is a half mile up Riverside, and she wanted to practice the drive.
Then it started stopping for nothing.
Wheeling and Riverside, the left turn by the old gas station that’s been a pawn shop, a church and a pawn shop again. Every time a student made that turn, clunk. I’d count one, two. Nothing came. No scooter, no truck, no dog. Just the empty lane and the student staring at me.
I watched the footage for those. I let it run past two seconds. I let it run a full minute. Nothing ever came down Riverside. The pedal just went down, held there a beat, and came back up.
It happened eleven times in October. Always that corner. Always the left turn toward the high school. I wrote all eleven down.
Rudy rebuilt the whole linkage. It did it again on the drive back from his garage.
Noor’s road test was the last week of October. In Indiana you can test in the school car, and the examiner sits where I usually sit. Noor was ready. She’d been ready since September.
I waited in the parking lot at the license branch. They came back after fifteen minutes. The examiner got out first and didn’t look at me. Noor got out second and was crying.
Fail. Examiner intervention. Wheeling and Riverside.
“I didn’t touch it,” the examiner told me later, by the door, very quietly, like she didn’t want anyone inside to hear. “I want you to know I had my feet tucked under the seat. I always do.” Then she asked if next time the school could send a different car.
Noor needed that license. Her mom leaves for work at five, and Noor was going to be the one driving her little brothers to school. Her retest was the next Saturday.
This is the part I did on purpose.
The state requires the dual brake for lessons. It doesn’t require it for the test. So the night before Noor’s retest, I took a socket set out to the lot and lay on my back in the passenger footwell of Car 2 like Rudy does. Four bolts and a clevis pin. The pedal and the rod came out in one piece, about the length of my arm, heavier than you’d think. I put it in the trunk of my own car because I didn’t want to leave it lying around the school lot where somebody would ask about it.
I’ll be honest about why. Some of it was Noor. Some of it was that I wanted to know what happened if it couldn’t stop the car.
She passed. I rode along in the back seat, which they let you do sometimes. At Wheeling and Riverside she signalled, checked, and turned left, and I counted one, two, with my hands on my knees, and nothing came, and nothing happened. She turned up toward the high school like it was any other street.
I drove home feeling like I’d fixed something.
That was Saturday. On Sunday I took Lainey out like I’d promised, in my car. It’s an old hatchback. It has one brake, on her side, and the pedal from Car 2 was still rattling around in the back, under the grocery bags, because I hadn’t decided what to do with it.
We practiced in the church lot on Wheeling first. Then she wanted to do the real drive, the one to her school. I said fine. I wanted to see her do it.
She was good. Better than I was at her age. She came up to Riverside, put her blinker on for the left, looked both ways twice like I taught her.
Clunk.
Not from the back. From under her. The car stopped so hard the grocery bags slid into the seat backs.
I looked at her feet. Her right one was on the floor, beside the pedal. Her left was tucked back under the seat. The brake was all the way down. It stayed down.
One, two.
Nothing came down Riverside. It’s been ten days, and we’ve been out six times, and nothing has come down Riverside yet. Every time we reach that corner, it holds the car there, and Lainey sits with her hands at ten and two and waits for me to tell her what to do.
I still have the pedal in my trunk. I tried putting it in the garage. It didn’t make any difference.
Last night we didn’t even make it out of the driveway. She had the car in reverse and her hand on the back of my seat to look over her shoulder, the way I taught her. The clunk came before she’d moved an inch. I asked her, as calmly as I could, to take her foot off the brake.
She looked at me, and then down at her shoes, and then back at me.
“Dad,” she said. “I’m not on it.”
AI was involved in writing this story.